Search This Blog

Tuesday, 20 September 2022

Bloody grammar schools again

I have written before about the trouble with grammar schools. This post from six years ago still stands up. It is depressing that despite all the evidence, it is such a persistent idea in this country's politics. 

I was on a zoom call today where colleagues mused that given the recent ministerial appointments made to the DfE, which are as much a metaphorical middle finger to the profession as the actual middle finger given by Andrea Jenkyns to protestors outside Downing Street earlier this year, a policy adjustment to expand selection at age 11 is almost inevitable.

There were some rational people on the call, who reasoned that rather than ignore this policy as a distraction from our core purpose, we should at least engage with it to attempt to mitigate it with a least worst option.

But something inside me snapped.

This is as far as I can go...

You can have your expansion of grammar schools but only if you:

  • Publicly drop the "levelling up" policy and admit that it was a lie
  • Explain that the reason for expanding selection is that you want to spend less on state education whilst pretending to support a meritocracy and also state that it is your policy ambition for many schools in the areas affected to be worse than they are today
  • Require all new grammar schools to accept only 50% by academic selection with the balance being allocated by lottery regardless of ability
  • Force all MPs that support the policy to send their children to secondary modern schools regardless of ability

    People who win rigged lotteries tend to support lotteries. They are also disinclined to examine the extent to which they were rigged.





    No comments: